Trine University Theatre announces 'Arsenic and Old Lace' cast

September 18, 2023

By Caitlin Mann
English ’25

Trine University Theatre will perform “Arsenic and Old Lace” this fall. 

Show dates for this classic dark comedy are: 7 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 9, 7 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 11, and 2 p.m. Sunday, Nov. 12, in the T. Furth Center for Performing Arts. Cast members have been selected and rehearsals have begun for the performance.  

“Arsenic and Old Lace,” written by Joseph Kesselring in 1939, is a dark comedy centered around Mortimer Brewster. Mortimer is a man living a happy life with a steady job and a new fiancé, until he visits his sweet, unassuming spinster aunts to announce his engagement. Although regarded as kind old ladies, there is more to Mortimer Brewster’s aunts than originally assumed. Brewster must battle the sinister plans of his aunts, combat his maniacal brother and protect his fiancé, all while keeping his own sanity intact. 

Cast members include: 

Mortimer – Aidan Smith, a mechanical engineering major from Connersville, Indiana 

Aunt Abby Brewster – Chantale Leavell, a biochemistry major from Gary, Indiana 

Aunt Martha Brewster – Sage Scherzer, a communication major from Elkhorn, Wisconsin 

Elaine – Evyenia Lawley, a science education major from Valparaiso, Indiana 

Jonathan Brewster – Sean Carpenter, a mechanical engineering major from Fort Wayne, Indiana 

Dr. Einstein – Muriel Mackie, a marketing major from Hillsdale, Michigan 

Teddy Brewster – Benton Knox, a mechanical engineering major from Indianapolis 

Rev. Dr. Harper – Parker Tillmon, a psychology major from Sturgis, Michigan 

Officer O’Hara – Michael Smith, assistant professor in the Department of Mathematics 

Officer Brophy – Andie Mendoza, a biomedical engineering major from LaGrange, Indiana 

Officer Kline – Tyler Kreider, a biology major from Trafalgar, Indiana 

Mr. Gibbs / Understudy 2 – Jason Branch, a psychology major from Chesterfield, Virginia 

Miss Witherspoon – Jo Drudge 

Lt. Rooney / Understudy 1 – Macy Bonifield, an elementary education major from Warsaw, Indiana 

 

Crew Members Include: 

Director: Lou Ann Homan 

Assistant Director: Jacob McNeal 

Stage Manager: Kat Kellogg, a marketing major from Bryan, Ohio 

Producer: Tim Hopp, Ph.D. 

 

Pricing information will be released at a later date. For more information, contact Director Lou Ann Homan at homanl@trine.edu 

Read More

All News
Dr. Angel Jennings

Trine University innovating to meet nursing education needs

May 8, 2026

As we celebrate National Nurses Week, the nursing workforce is under pressure across the country. Staff shortages, high patient acuity and increasing complexity of care delivery are besetting our healthcare systems. Nursing education programs are being asked to provide graduates who will step directly into practice - faster, more efficiently and with the ability to cope at an increasingly fast pace with changing environments.

1/3
Dr. Kline presenting award to Dr. Liu

Trine faculty receive annual awards

May 6, 2026

Trine University honored faculty members during its annual year-end awards ceremony, held prior to Commencement on Saturday, May 2.

2/3
Mitch Daniels speaking at podium

Daniels offers graduates advice for promising, uncertain times

May 4, 2026

Mitch Daniels, former governor of the state of Indiana and former president of Purdue University, shared advice with graduates he said were entering a world he described as “the most promising and most uncertain and treacherous” as Trine University held Commencement ceremonies on May 2.

3/3